Wondira · Sample units · Grades 6–8 · Argument writing
Sample unit: Argument writing (Writing · 6–8)
Full middle-school writing unit: claims, evidence, counterclaims, fallacies, essay structure.
Students build a claim, add evidence, and answer a counterpoint. This grades 6 to 8 writing unit moves from a model to practice and a check, and the piece can go in the portfolio.
Unit map
Lesson 1: Building a claim
A claim is a statement you can argue for with evidence. A good claim is specific, debatable, and focused.
Worked example
Weak: Phones are bad. Make it stronger.
- Be specific
- Make it debatable
Answer: Students should not use phones during class because they reduce focus.
Second example
Is "Water is wet" a claim?
- Can anyone disagree?
Answer: No, it is a fact.
Practice
- Write a claim about school start times. Hint: Position plus reason. → School should start later because teens need more sleep.
- Make this specific: Sports are good. Hint: Good how? → Team sports teach cooperation and resilience.
- Turn a fact into a claim: Many kids play video games. Hint: Add a position. → Video games can improve problem-solving when time is limited.
Three-question check
Lesson 2: Finding strong evidence
Strong evidence is relevant, specific, and credible. Facts, data, and expert quotations beat vague opinions. Always connect evidence back to the claim.
Worked example
Claim: School should start later. Weak evidence?
- “Everyone is tired” is vague
Answer: Prefer sleep-study data over vibes
Second example
Better evidence type?
- Peer-reviewed sleep research on teens
Answer: Credible research
Practice
- Name one weak evidence habit. Hint: Vague or unrelated. → Anecdotes only / no source / off-topic quotes
- How do you introduce a quote? Hint: According to… → With a signal phrase and citation
- Relevant means… Hint: On-topic. → Clearly supports the claim
Three-question check
Lesson 3: Addressing counterclaims
A counterclaim is the other side. Strong arguments name it fairly, then rebut with reason and evidence. Straw-manning weakens trust.
Worked example
Claim: Ban phones in class. Counterclaim?
- Phones can be learning tools
Answer: Some say phones support research, then rebut with distraction data
Second example
Fair vs straw man?
- Fair = strongest other view
- Straw = cartoon version
Answer: Use the fair version
Practice
- What is a rebuttal? Hint: Answer the other side. → Your response that shows why the counterclaim is weaker
- Why address counterclaims? Hint: Reader trust. → Builds credibility; shows you considered alternatives
- Bad move? Hint: Ad hominem. → Insulting opponents instead of evidence
Three-question check
Lesson 4: Logical reasoning
Reasoning connects evidence to the claim. Watch for common fallacies: false cause, hasty generalization, either/or. Clear “because” chains help readers follow.
Worked example
Fallacy: “It rained after I washed the car, so washing causes rain.”
- Correlation ≠ causation
Answer: False cause
Second example
Strengthen: “Homework helps because…”
- Add mechanism + evidence
Answer: Because spaced practice improves retention (study X)
Practice
- Name a fallacy. Hint: Bad logic pattern. → Hasty generalization / false dilemma / ad hominem…
- What does a warrant do? Hint: The because bridge. → Explains why evidence supports the claim
- Either/or fallacy ignores… Hint: False dilemma. → Middle options
Three-question check
Lesson 5: Argument essay
A full argument essay: hook + claim, body paragraphs with evidence and reasoning, a counterclaim + rebuttal, and a conclusion that answers “so what?” Keep tone respectful and precise.
Worked example
Minimum body structure?
- Point
- Evidence
- Explanation
Answer: PEE / CER pattern
Second example
Conclusion should…
- Not only repeat
- Widen significance
Answer: Synthesize + implication
Practice
- List essay sections. Hint: Standard shape. → Intro/claim, body, counterclaim, conclusion
- Tone tip? Hint: Not ranting. → Respectful, precise, evidence-first
- One revision check? Hint: Cut drift. → Every paragraph still serves the claim
Three-question check
Parent / mentor binder
| Lesson | Check | Status |
|---|
- Unit average
- —
- Next
- —